Genetic identification method for two subspecies of the Indonesian short-finned eel, Anguilla bicolor, using an allelic discrimination technique
© Tanaka et al.; licensee Springer. 2014
Received: 7 July 2014
Accepted: 21 August 2014
Published: 14 September 2014
There is an increasing pressure on tropical species of the freshwater eel genus Anguilla for use in aquaculture, so species identification methods are needed to monitor these activities and to facilitate conservation efforts. A method was developed to genetically distinguish two subspecies of the Indonesian short-finned eel, Anguilla bicolor, based on an allelic discrimination technique.
A single DNA nucleotide substitution in the mitochondrial DNA 16S rRNA gene was employed to identify the two subspecies where Anguilla bicolor bicolor and Anguilla bicolor pacifica possessed adenine and guanine, respectively. This substitution was highly conserved at 100% in A. bicolor bicolor (108/108) and 99.9% in A. bicolor pacifica (181/182), and the misidentification rate was estimated to be 0.34%. Subsequently, fluorescent-labeled oligo probes and PCR primers were designed and succeeded to clearly distinguish the two subspecies. Further, the other ten anguillid species that may be sympatrically distributed with A. bicolor showed negative results.
The method developed in this study is useful to accurately identify the two subspecies of A. bicolor and can contribute to ecological studies, stock management, and conservation.
KeywordsAllelic discrimination Anguilla bicolor Indonesian short-finned eel Genetic identification Red list
Freshwater eels of the genus Anguilla have catadromous life histories in which they spawn in the open ocean and grow in freshwater or estuaries (Aoyama ). Anguillid glass eels have been harvested when they recruit to estuaries for use in aquaculture because artificial production of anguillids has not yet been established at a commercial scale. The populations of temperate species such as the European eel Anguilla anguilla and the Japanese eel Anguilla japonica, however, have decreased drastically in recent decades and are now classified as being Critically Endangered (A2bd + 4bd ver 3.1) and Endangered (A2bc ver 3.1) species by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) since 2010 and 2014, respectively (Jacoby and Gollock [2014a], [b]). As an alternative to these endangered temperate species, tropical anguillids such as Anguilla bicolor, Anguilla luzonensis, and Anguilla marmorata have been introduced into aquaculture in recent years (TY, unpublished data). Especially for sale in Japan, A. bicolor has been harvested, raised, and processed in Indonesia and has already been mass-marketed in supermarkets. The latest version of the IUCN Red List, however, evaluated the stock status of A. bicolor being under threat by such rapidly increasing utilization, and the category of the species has been changed to the Near Threatened after previously being categorized as being the Least Concern in 2010 (Jacoby and Gollock [2014c]).
A. bicolor is further divided taxonomically into the two subspecies of Anguilla bicolor bicolor in the Indian Ocean and Anguilla bicolor pacifica in the western North Pacific and northern Indonesian Seas (Ege ; Watanabe ). These two subspecies, however, are almost identical in their morphological characteristics except for the mode of their number of vertebrate (Watanabe et al. ), and only genetic characteristics enable them to be clearly divided into different subspecies. Currently, the most reliable information for distinguishing the two subspecies of A. bicolor is DNA nucleotide substitutions in a hypervariable region of the d-loop in their mitochondrial DNA (Minegishi et al. ).
Despite being genetically different, the latest assessment by the IUCN (ver 2014.1) considered the subspecies of some anguillids including A. bicolor together, due to a lack of basic ecological information for each subspecies (Jacoby and Gollock [2014c]). Filling in such major gaps in the information such as species range and stock status available about tropical anguillids is critical to establish an effective management plan for these commercially utilized freshwater eels. However, one of the major obstacles for the ecological study in the tropical anguillid species is that the species identification with morphological characteristics is impossible (Ege ; Watanabe ). Accordingly, in this study, we developed a method to genetically distinguish the two subspecies of A. bicolor using a subspecies-specific DNA nucleotide substitution detected by an allelic discrimination analysis based on polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Because the glass eels of other anguillid species have been collected as bycatch with A. bicolor in tropical regions and introduced to aquaculture as unidentified mixed anguillid species in Japan (TY, unpublished data), the ability of the method to distinguish the two subspecies of A. bicolor from the other sympatrically distributed species in the Indian Ocean and the western North Pacific was also examined. The method developed in this study achieves a high-throughput analysis in a few hours and thus can be applied for both scientific and commercial purposes.
Glass eels of A. bicolor were collected at two localities where only one of the two subspecies was known to recruit (Ege ; Watanabe ; Minegishi et al. ). The A. bicolor bicolor specimens were collected at the coast of the Sukabumi, West Java, Indonesia in September 2013 and imported to Japan for aquaculture (n = 108). The A. bicolor pacifica specimens were collected at the river mouth of the Cagayan River, northern Luzon, Philippines in November and December 2011 (n = 182) (Aoyama et al. ). Species identification of the specimens was carried out by determining partial DNA nucleotide sequences of the d-loop in the mitochondrial DNA for randomly selected sub-samples (A. bicolor bicolor, n = 23 from Indonesia; A. bicolor pacifica, n = 28 from Philippines). PCR primers of L15774 (5′-ACA TGA ATT GGA GGA ATA CCA GT-3′; Shields and Kocher ) and H16498aj (5′-CCT GAA ATA GGA ACC AAA TG-3′; modified from the original H16498 in Kocher et al. ) were used as described in detail elsewhere (Yoshinaga et al. , ).
2.2 Designing PCR primers and probe for allelic discrimination
2.3 Intra- and inter-subspecies nucleotide variation
To determine the intra- and inter-subspecies DNA nucleotide variation in the region for the allelic discrimination, partial DNA nucleotide sequences of the 16S rRNA gene were analyzed for A. bicolor bicolor (n = 108) and A. bicolor pacifica (n = 182) with universal PCR primers of 16S-ar and 16S-br (5′-CGC CTG TTT ATC AAA AAC AT-3′ and 5′-CTC CGG TTT GAA CTC AGA TCA-3′, respectively; Palumbi et al. ). The specimens with a unique haplotype were further analyzed by determining the DNA nucleotide sequence of the d-loop region to confirm the subspecies identification.
2.4 Sensitivity and specificity of the allelic discrimination
To verify the capabilities of the method developed in this study, four kinds of tests were performed: (1) To determine the sensitivity of the method, a serial dilution between 10 ng/μL and 10 fg/μL, resulting in a range between 50 ng and 50 fg in each reaction, of the total genomic DNA was used in the assay. The total genomic DNA was prepared using a DNeasy Blood & Tissue Kit (Qiagen, Venlo, the Netherlands), and the DNA concentration was quantified using a Qubit Fluorometric Quantitiation system with a dsDNA HS Assay Kit (Life Technologies, Waltham, MA, USA). (2) Three and four haplotypes in A. bicolor bicolor and A. bicolor pacifica, respectively (see the ‘Results’ section), were tested at the DNA concentration of 1 ng/μL each (5 ng in each reaction). (3) To achieve a high-throughput and cost-effective method, the template DNA was prepared by a HotSHOT method (Truett et al. ) with a slight modification. A small portion of tissue was boiled in 50 μL of 50 mM sodium hydroxide at 95°C for 20 min, neutralized with 5 μL of 1 M Tris–HCl, pH 8, and then the supernatant was used for the allelic discrimination. (4) As the other anguillid species that are commercially harvested with A. bicolor, the Indian Ocean species of Anguilla bengalensis bengalensis, Anguilla bengalensis labiata, Anguilla mossambica, and the western North Pacific species of Anguilla celebesensis, Anguilla japonica, Anguilla luzonensis, and the common or possibly present species in the two oceans of Anguilla borneensis, Anguilla interioris, Anguilla marmorata, and Anguilla obscura were examined at the DNA concentration of 1 ng/μL each (5 ng in each reaction).
A total of 20 μL of reaction contained 10 μL of a TaqMan Universal PCR master mix (Applied Biosystems), 0.4 μM each AD-Abic-16S-F1278v2 and AD-Abic-16S-R1420 primers, 3.8 pmol each of the AD-BBI-16S-p and AD-BPA-16S-p probes, and 5 μL of template DNA. The reaction was carried out with an ABI PRISM 7000/7300 Sequence Detection Systems (Applied Biosystems) with a thermal profile of an initial step at 50°C for 2 min and 95°C for 10 min, and then 50 cycles of 95°C for 15 s, 60°C for 15 s, and 72°C for 45 s. The allelic discrimination analyses were performed according to the manufacturer's protocol (Applied Biosystems).
The DNA nucleotide sequences of the seven haplotypes were deposited in the DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank databases with accession numbers of AB971267 to AB971269 (BBI-HT1-3 in A. bicolor bicolor) and AB971270 to AB971273 (BPA-HT1-4 in A. bicolor pacifica).
3.2 Allelic discrimination analyses
In the second test, among the total seven haplotypes in A. bicolor, one haplotype of BPA-HT2 in A. bicolor pacifica was wrongly discriminated as A. bicolor bicolor as was predicted from its nucleotide substitution at the 1,318th position (Figure 2), while the other six haplotypes were precisely identified as each subspecies (Figure 3b).
When the total genomic DNA prepared by the HotSHOT method was applied in the reaction, no amplification was observed. In contrast, 1/10 dilution of the supernatant with water significantly improved the amplification and resulted in the successful discrimination (data not shown). The DNA concentrations for the 1/10 diluted supernatant, determined by the Qubit system, were 234.7 ± 106.5 pg/μL (average ± s.d.; range, 56.8 to 354.0; n = 10) and were found to be in the range determined by the sensitivity test (Figure 3a).
The other ten anguillid species were tested with the primers and probe designed for A. bicolor, and all were discriminated as being negative (Figure 3c).
DNA nucleotide sequencing provides the most reliable results for species identification in the genus Anguilla, but it requires a high cost in time and labor and stable environment for sophisticated laboratory equipments (Yoshinaga et al. ; Aoyama et al. ). To compensate for these disadvantages, alternative methods such as the species-specific PCR have been developed. Watanabe et al. () and Minegishi et al. () developed a method to identify egg or larval specimens of the Japanese eel A. japonica onboard during oceanic sampling surveys of the spawning area by using an A. japonica-specific fluorescent-labeled probe, and this contributed to the discovery of naturally spawned eggs of this species for the first time (Tsukamoto et al. ; Yoshinaga et al. ). Itoi et al. () also reported a method to distinguish the commercially distributed species of A. japonica and A. anguilla using specific probes for each species. In addition, to identify seven species/subspecies of Anguilla in Indonesian waters, Fahmi et al. () used PCR primers specific to each species/subspecies. Batch analysis based on the species-specific PCR primer to verify the presence of A. japonica has also been recently reported (Suzuki et al. ).
In this study, we developed a method to distinguish the two subspecies of A. bicolor whose morphological characteristics are not sufficient to identify them accurately. To determine the subspecies-specific DNA nucleotide substitution, we compared the sequences of the partial fragments of the mitochondrial 16S rRNA gene and detected a transition substitution of adenine and guanine, which were specific to A. bicolor bicolor and A. bicolor pacifica, respectively (Figure 1), except for the rare haplotype found in A. bicolor pacifica (Figure 2). Subsequently, we designed fluorescent-labeled oligo probes to detect the subspecies-specific single DNA nucleotide substitution by the allelic discrimination method. In PCR-based identification methods, the DNA nucleotide substitutions in a single species (intra-species variation) should be carefully taken into account, especially to distinguish genetically closed groups such as subspecies. However, it is hard to comprehensively catalog the haplotypes in each species due to a sampling difficulty especially in the tropical anguillid species whose species ranges are not yet known. On the other hand, A. bicolor bicolor and A. bicolor pacifica distribute widely in the Indian Ocean and the western North Pacific, but each subspecies shares common gene pool even for the A. bicolor bicolor present at the western and eastern sides of the Indian Ocean (Minegishi et al. ). This allowed us to assume that the specimens of the two subspecies collected at a single locality in the Indian Ocean (Indonesia) and the western North Pacific (Philippines) represented the genetic characteristics of each subspecies. We examined intra-subspecies variation with a large number of specimens of both A. bicolor bicolor and A. bicolor pacifica and identified three and four haplotypes, respectively (Figure 2). Frequencies of each haplotype were strongly skewed, and the commonest type was present in more than 97% of the individuals in each subspecies. One haplotype in A. bicolor pacifica (BPA-HT2), however, possessed the substitution of the A. bicolor bicolor type and resulted in the misidentification by the allelic discrimination (Figure 3b). On the other hand, the other haplotypes were clearly discriminated even though the substitution existed in the probe binding region (Figure 2). Accordingly, among the 290 specimens of A. bicolor examined in this study, only 1 specimen had a substitution causing misidentification, and thus, an error rate was estimated to be 0.34% (1/290).
In the allelic discrimination assay with the HotSHOT method, 1/10 dilution of the supernatant yielded stable results, probably due to an unidentified inhibiting factor(s) in the original solution since the method did not guarantee the uncontaminated DNA fraction, but is still suitable for the PCR (Truett et al. ). The HotSHOT method does not require a digestion enzyme or purification column and is appropriate for a low-cost and high-throughput allelic discrimination assay.
We also tested the ability of the method to distinguish the two subspecies of A. bicolor from the other anguillid species. Ten species, which have been known to sympatrically recruit with A. bicolor (Ege ; Watanabe ; Yoshinaga et al. ), were examined, and all showed negative results (Figure 3c). This might be due to mismatch at the 3′-end of the forward primer (Figure 1), and PCR amplification did not occur, or did with significantly lesser efficiency, in the other species. However, careful attention should be paid to apply the method to the other species, because haplotypes have been almost solely studied in temperate species such as the Japanese eel A. japonica and the European eel A. anguilla, and information on tropical species is scarce. Future investigation of haplotype diversity is essential to evaluate the usefulness of the method to be used for the other anguillid species of A. bicolor.
The Indonesian archipelago has been known to have the highest species richness of anguillid eels, and 7 (Aoyama et al. ) or 9 (Sugeha et al. ) among the total of 19 species/subspecies have been reported to occur. These include the two subspecies of A. bicolor, but the boundary or overlapping parts of the ranges of the two subspecies have not yet been established. Areas that have currents from both the Indian Ocean and North Pacific, such as Malaysia and Thailand, may have some recruitment of either or both of the two A. bicolor subspecies. There has been some progress in the ecological study of A. bicolor bicolor (Chino and Arai [2010a], [b]; Arai et al. , ; Arai and Chino ), and this should be expanded to cover the wider distribution range of this species in the Indian Ocean and the western North Pacific to accumulate information for assessing its population status. The method developed in this study can be helpful to clarify the distribution ranges of the two subspecies of A. bicolor, and such basic ecological information should be considered to evaluate the status of these subspecies, because the increasing commercial fishing activity may quickly cause their populations to decline as have the temperate anguillid species.
This study was financially supported by a grant from the Fisheries Agency of Japan to TY and AS, and a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C) from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (No. 40111489) to AS, AJ, and TY. The authors would like to thank MJ Miller and two anonymous reviewers for helping to improve the manuscript.
- Aoyama J: Life history and evolution of migration in catadromous eels (genus Anguilla ). Aqua-BioScience Monographs 2009, 2: 1–42. 10.5047/absm.2009.00201.0001View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Aoyama J, Nishida M, Tsukamoto K: Molecular phylogeny and evolution of the freshwater eel, genus Anguilla . Mol Phylogen Evol 2001, 20: 450–459. 10.1006/mpev.2001.0959View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Aoyama J, Yoshinaga T, Shinoda A, Shirotori F, Yambot AV, Han Y-S: Seasonal changes in species composition of glass eels of the genus Anguilla (Teleostei: Anguillidae) recruiting to the Cagayan River. Pacific Sci, Luzon Island, the Philippines; 2014.Google Scholar
- Arai T, Chino N: Timing of maturation of a tropical eel, Anguilla bicolor bicolor in Malaysia. J Appl Ichthyol 2013, 29: 271–273. 10.1111/jai.12040View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Arai T, Chino N, Zulkifli SZ, Ismail A: Notes on the occurrence of the tropical eel Anguilla bicolor bicolor in Peninsular Malaysia, Malaysia. J Fish Biol 2012, 80: 692–697. 10.1111/j.1095-8649.2011.03154.xView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Arai T, Chino N, Le DQ: Migration and habitat use of the tropical eels Anguilla marmorata and A. bicolor pacifica in Vietnam. Aquat Ecol 2013, 47: 57–65. 10.1007/s10452-012-9424-xView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chino N, Arai T: Habitat use and habitat transitions in the tropical eel, Anguilla bicolor bicolor . Env Biol Fishes 2010, 89: 571–578. 10.1007/s10641-010-9677-yView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chino N, Arai T: Occurrence of marine resident tropical eel Anguilla bicolor bicolor in Indonesia. Mar Biol 2010, 157: 1075–1081. 10.1007/s00227-009-1388-6View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ege V: A revision of the genus Anguilla Shaw, a systematic, phylogenetic and geographical study. Dana Rep 1939, 16: 1–256.Google Scholar
- Fahmi MR, Solihin DD, Soewardi K, Pouyaud L, Shao Z, Berrebi P: A novel semi-multiplex PCR assay for identification of tropical eels of genus Anguilla in Indonesian waters. Fish Sci 2013, 79: 185–191. 10.1007/s12562-012-0587-0View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Itoi S, Nakaya M, Kaneko G, Kondo H, Sezaki K, Watabe S: Rapid identification of eels Anguilla japonica and Anguilla anguilla by polymerase chain reaction with single nucleotide polymorphism-based specific probes. Fish Sci 2005, 71: 1356–1364. 10.1111/j.1444-2906.2005.01102.xView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jacoby D, Gollock M: Anguilla anguilla. In: IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, Ver; 2014.Google Scholar
- Jacoby D, Gollock M: Anguilla japonica. In: IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, Ver; 2014.Google Scholar
- Jacoby D, Gollock M: Anguilla bicolor. In: IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, Ver; 2014.Google Scholar
- Kocher TD, Thomas WK, Meyer A, Edwards SV, Pääbo S, Villablanca FX, Wilson AC: Dynamics of mitochondrial DNA evolution in animals: amplification and sequencing with conserved primers. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1989, 86: 6196–6200. 10.1073/pnas.86.16.6196PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Minegishi Y, Yoshinaga T, Aoyama J, Tsukamoto K: Species identification of Anguilla japonica by real-time PCR based on a sequence detection system: a practical application to eggs and larvae. ICES J Mar Sci 2009, 66: 1915–1918. 10.1093/icesjms/fsp158View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Minegishi Y, Gagnaire P-A, Aoyama J, Bosc P, Feunteun E, Tsukamoto K, Berrebi P: Present and past genetic connectivity of the Indo-Pacific tropical eel Anguilla bicolor . J Biogeography 2012, 39: 408–420. 10.1111/j.1365-2699.2011.02603.xView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Palumbi SR, Martin AP, Romano SL, McMillan WO, Stice L, Grabowski G: The simple fool's guide to PCR. University of Hawaii, Honolulu, Department of Zoology; 1991.Google Scholar
- Shields GF, Kocher TD: Phylogenetic relationships of North American ursids based on analysis of mitochondrial DNA. Evolution 1991, 45: 218–221. 10.2307/2409495View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sugeha HY, Suharti SR, Wouthuyzen S, Sumadhiharga K: Biodiversity, distribution and abundance of the tropical anguillid eels in the Indonesian waters. Mar Res Indonesia 2008, 33: 129–137.Google Scholar
- Suzuki H, Kimoto M, Yoshizoe Y, Tsuneyoshi T, Asai N, Ueda M, Kubota H, Kubota T: DNA analysis method for detecting the mixing of foreign species of eel among many Anguilla japonica eels. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi 2011, 77: 896–901. (in Japanese) 10.2331/suisan.77.896View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Truett GE, Heeger P, Mynatt RL, Truett AA, Walker JA, Warman ML: Preparation of PCR-quality mouse genomic DNA with hot sodium hydroxide and tris (HotSHOT). Biotechniques 2000, 29: 52–54.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tsukamoto K, Chow S, Otake T, Kurogi H, Mochioka N, Miller MJ, Aoyama J, Kimura S, Watanabe S, Yoshinaga T, Shinoda A, Kuroki M, Oya M, Watanabe T, Hata K, Ijiri S, Kazeto Y, Nomura K, Tanaka H: Oceanic spawning ecology of freshwater eels in the western North Pacific. Nat Commun 2011, 2: 179. 10.1038/ncomms1174PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Watanabe S: Taxonomy of the freshwater eels, genus Anguilla Schrank, 1798. In Eel biology. Edited by: Aida K, Tsukamoto K, Yamauchi K. Springer, Tokyo; 2003:3–18. 10.1007/978-4-431-65907-5_1View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Watanabe S, Minegishi Y, Yoshinaga T, Aoyama J, Tsukamoto K: A quick method for species identification of the Japanese eel ( Anguilla japonica ) using real-time PCR: an onboard application for use during sampling surveys. Mar Biotechnol 2004, 6: 566–574. 10.1007/s10126-004-1000-5View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Watanabe S, Miller MJ, Aoyama J, Tsukamoto K: Evaluation of the population structure of Anguilla bicolor and A. bengalensis using total number of vertebrae and consideration of the subspecies concept for the genus Anguilla . Ecol Freshwat Fish 2014, 23: 77–85. 10.1111/eff.12076View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yoshinaga T, Miller MJ, Yokouchi K, Otake T, Kimura S, Aoyama J, Watanabe S, Shinoda A, Oya M, Miyazaki S, Zenimoto K, Sudo R, Takahashi T, Ahn H, Manabe R, Hagihara S, Morioka H, Itakura H, Machida M, Ban K, Shiozaki M, Ai B, Tsukamoto K: Genetic identification and morphology of naturally spawned eggs of the Japanese eel Anguilla japonica collected in the western North Pacific. Fish Sci 2011, 77: 983–992. 10.1007/s12562-011-0418-8View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yoshinaga T, Aoyama J, Shinoda A, Watanabe S, Azanza RV, Tsukamoto K: Occurrence and biological characteristics of glass eels of the Japanese eel Anguilla japonica at the Cagayan River of Luzon Island, Philippines in 2009. Zool Stud 2014, 53: 13. 10.1186/1810-522X-53-13View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.